Noble or Stupid

[Bigg Joe]

I am re-reading OotP right now, and I'm on the part where Harry and Hermione is taking Umbridge to the forest...But, when Harry had the dream about Sirius being tortured and wanting to rescue him, do ya'll think he was Noble or Stupid?

I believe he was stupid. When I first read it, I believed him to be Noble, but now, I relies how idiotic he was for dragging his friends into danger...

[dracosgirl]

I aggree. Also when he uses Umbridge's fire to check for Sirius and Kretcher tells him that Sirius is gone you would think that he wouldn't have believed Kretcher. I think he was being noble to the point of being stupid.

[Bigg Joe]

Yeah, that's true. And, he should of relies, that Snape had to act the way he did when that big incident they had at Umbridge office